Etiquette



DP Etiquette

First rule: Don't be a jackass.

Other rules: Do not attack or insult people you disagree with. Engage with facts, logic and beliefs. Out of respect for others, please provide some sources for the facts and truths you rely on if you are asked for that. If emotion is getting out of hand, get it back in hand. To limit dehumanizing people, don't call people or whole groups of people disrespectful names, e.g., stupid, dumb or liar. Insulting people is counterproductive to rational discussion. Insult makes people angry and defensive. All points of view are welcome, right, center, left and elsewhere. Just disagree, but don't be belligerent or reject inconvenient facts, truths or defensible reasoning.

Friday, March 7, 2025

Deep research: What is the likelihood that djt is working for Putin?

Bottom line: This analysis puts the likelihood that djt is a Russian asset at 75%-85%.

Q: What is the approximate likelihood that Trump is working for Russia or Putin based on all available relevant information including Trump's mendacity, sympathy for dictators, amenability to be corrupted and his behaviors especially since 2016?

A: The question of whether Donald Trump is acting as an agent of Russian interests, whether through coercion, financial compromise, or ideological alignment, has persisted since his 2016 presidential campaign. This analysis synthesizes evidence from Trump’s financial history, political behavior, policy decisions, and testimonies from intelligence professionals to estimate the likelihood of such a relationship.
 
Historical Context: Early Ties to Russian Networks
Soviet-Era Cultivation Efforts

Multiple accounts from former Soviet intelligence officers allege that Trump was cultivated as a potential asset during his 1987 visit to Moscow. Yuri Shvets, a former KGB major, and Alnur Mussayev, ex-head of Kazakhstan’s intelligence service, claim Trump was targeted for recruitment due to his business ambitions and political naivety1 6 14. While no smoking gun confirms formal recruitment, Trump’s subsequent financial reliance on post-Soviet oligarchs—evidenced by $109 million in all-cash purchases of Trump properties between 2003 and 2017—aligns with patterns of money laundering and kompromat accumulation 6 8.

Financial Dependence on Russian Capital
After U.S. banks distanced themselves from Trump following his 1990s bankruptcies, Russian-linked entities became critical financiers. Trump’s sons, Donald Jr. and Eric, openly acknowledged reliance on Russian capital, with Eric stating in 2014: “We have all the funding we need out of Russia” 6 14. This dependency created vulnerabilities, as debt to opaque Russian entities could be leveraged for political concessions.


Post-2016 Behavior: Policy Alignment with Kremlin Objectives
Undermining NATO and Defending Russian Aggression

Trump’s repeated disparagement of NATO—calling it “obsolete” and threatening withdrawal—mirrored long-standing Kremlin goals to fracture Western alliances 10 13. His refusal to publicly condemn Russia’s 2014 annexation of Crimea or its 2022 invasion of Ukraine, coupled with blaming NATO expansion for provoking conflict, further aligned with Putin’s narratives 3 13.

Sanctions Relief and Cyber Truce
In early 2025, Trump reportedly directed the Treasury and State Departments to identify sanctions on Russia for potential easing and suspended U.S. offensive cyber operations against Moscow 2 15. These unilateral moves, made without consulting European allies, directly advanced Putin’s objectives of economic recovery and reduced cyber vulnerability 2 7.
 
Compromising Evidence and Counterintelligence Concerns
Obstruction of Investigations
The Mueller Report (2019) documented 272 contacts between Trump associates and Russia-linked operatives, none disclosed to authorities 1. While the investigation found insufficient evidence of criminal conspiracy, it highlighted systemic deception, including Paul Manafort’s sharing of campaign data with Russian intelligence 1 6. The Senate Intelligence Committee’s 2020 report labeled multiple Trump associates as “counterintelligence threats,” citing their susceptibility to foreign influence 6 12.

Amplification of Russian Disinformation
Trump consistently echoed Kremlin propaganda, including false claims that Ukraine—not Russia—initiated the 2022 war 3 13. His endorsement of Rudy Giuliani’s efforts to spread debunked allegations about Hunter Biden’s dealings in Ukraine paralleled Russian active measures to discredit U.S. institutions 6 12.


Psychological and Ideological Factors
Admiration for Authoritarian Leadership
Trump’s public admiration for Putin’s “strongman” leadership style, including praise for the 2022 invasion as “savvy,” reflects ideological alignment with autocratic governance 10 13. His threats to withdraw from NATO, impose tariffs on allies, and undermine democratic norms (e.g., suggesting “lifetime” presidential terms) mirror Putin’s consolidation of power 10 11.

Rejection of Democratic Accountability
Trump’s attacks on inspectors general, whistleblowers, and independent media—culminating in the 2025 purge of ethics officials—demonstrate a preference for opacity conducive to foreign manipulation 5 10. His dismissal of U.S. intelligence assessments on Russian election interference further eroded safeguards against foreign influence 1 6.
 
Probabilistic Assessment
Cumulative Evidence of Compromise

Elon Musk’s AI, Grok, analyzed public data from 1980–2025 and estimated a 75–85% likelihood that Trump is a “Putin-compromised asset,” citing financial ties, policy alignment, and refusal to criticize Russia despite attacking allies 6. This aligns with intelligence assessments noting Trump’s susceptibility to kompromat and repeated acts benefiting Moscow 14 16.

Counterarguments and Uncertainty
Skeptics argue Trump’s behavior stems from transactional self-interest rather than direct coercion. His real estate ventures in Russia, though largely unrealized, may reflect a pragmatic pursuit of profit rather than subservience 7 16. Additionally, the absence of classified intercepts or financial records leaves room for alternative explanations, such as naive admiration for Putin 15.
 
Conclusion
Based on documented financial dependencies, policy decisions favoring Russian interests, and corroborated intelligence allegations, the likelihood of Trump acting as a Russian asset falls between 75% and 85%. While definitive proof remains elusive, the preponderance of circumstantial evidence—spanning four decades—suggests a relationship exceeding mere coincidence or ideological affinity. This assessment underscores the need for continued scrutiny of Trump’s financial networks and foreign engagements to mitigate risks to U.S. democratic institutions. (emphasis added)

Whadda ya think? Isn't Perplexity a total hoot? Oh yeah, and the analysis of djt working for Russia too!

What led to this little Q&A was commentary about a 277 page court filing last year by an FBI agent wanting a search warrant regarding Russians screwing with American elections. The Russians were conducting a covert effort called Doppelganger. Doppelganger is the German word for a double of a living person. Basically, the Russians were posting fake, anti-American content using the trademarks of major US news outlets to hide the fact that it was all a gigantic Russian hoax. 


Part of page 1 of 277 pages