Pragmatic politics focused on the public interest for those uncomfortable with America's two-party system and its way of doing politics. Considering the interface of politics with psychology, cognitive biology, social behavior, morality and history.
Etiquette
DP Etiquette
First rule: Don't be a jackass. Most people are good.
Other rules: Do not attack or insult people you disagree with. Engage with facts, logic and beliefs. Out of respect for others, please provide some sources for the facts and truths you rely on if you are asked for that. If emotion is getting out of hand, get it back in hand. To limit dehumanizing people, don't call people or whole groups of people disrespectful names, e.g., stupid, dumb or liar. Insulting people is counterproductive to rational discussion. Insult makes people angry and defensive. All points of view are welcome, right, center, left and elsewhere. Just disagree, but don't be belligerent or reject inconvenient facts, truths or defensible reasoning.
According to some reporting, the House vote to impeach Hegseth yesterday failed because some dems didn’t show up for the vote. Pelosi was busy receiving an award for whatever, while another was at a doctor’s visit. Some other dems got ‘stuck in traffic’. What a display of unity and competence. /s
Dem party elites doing their thing
One Republican voted to impeach, just one. Arguably, that signals the MAGA party’s intend to stay defiant and MAGAfied, the election results be damned. Also signaling MAGA party defiance and stubborn MAGAfication, House MAGA politicians voted to make the hyper-aggressive MAGA extremist Jim Jordan their leader in the next congress. Jordan, always being full of hot piss and rancid vinegar, ain’t gonna compromise on anything. The question is how well he will be able to hold MAGA party unity together in the House. That will be interesting to watch.
Jordan is pissed off and in no mood to compromise on anything
Maybe after the next congress is sworn in, when all the cats are in the same room at the same time, the dems can collect themselves and arrange to vote again on impeaching Hegseth. Yesterday’s House vote was a procedural move to shelve the impeachment, not a direct vote rejecting the individual articles on their merits.
Apparently there is some grumpiness among some dem elites and rank and file with how the impeachment vote played out. For example, an article, Hakeem Jeffries’ Future Questioned After Pete Hegseth Impeachment Failure, raises the issue of displeasure with current dem party leadership. Will the dems toss Jeffries and Schumer, or will the dems’ crappy but long-standing dem party system of seniority over competence keep those to disasters in power? The old dem guard isn’t going to willingly let go of power. The dem establishment is backed by special interest money. They will have to be forced out. That’s another interesting thing to watch.
Q1: Does the dem party need a strong leader to herd the dems cats, e.g., as shown below?
Strong dem leader herding the dem cats
Q2: Has the MAGA party leadership clearly signaled its intention to fight tooth, claw, and poison fang in opposition of everything or nearly everything the herd of cats will try to do in the next congress, the voters be damned?
Analysis of the 2026 election results will continue to dribble out for at least the next couple of months. But data from national exit polling arguably is maybe cause for cautious optimism tinged with caution about defense of democracy and the rule of law against radical right American authoritarianism and kleptocracy.
National exit polling reported by NBC News indicates there is a deep split in voter sentiment. On the pro-democracy side, (1) 71% of voters said Congress was not doing enough to provide checks and balances on the presidency, (2) 63% disapproved of Trump’s performance, including 54% who strongly disapproved, (3) 62% said he prioritized his personal interests over the country’s interests, and (4) independents voted Dem by 58% to 38%, and moderates by 66% to 32%.
But on the pro-authoritarianism side, for voters identifying as Repub, 93% voted MAGA, with 97% of conservatives voting for MAGA. Of people who voted for Trump in 2024, 91% voted MAGA in 2026. For those people, they apparently don’t see vote-changing levels of failure, corruption, cruelty or lawlessness. To them MAGA elites are still better and still worth voting for than the Dems.
The 90% figure on concerns about corruption does not show a shared understanding of who is corrupt or what accountability requires. On which party could better handle government corruption, 37% chose Dems, 30% Repubs, and 32% neither. Among voters who called corruption crucial or a major factor, 41% nevertheless voted Republican. That means a hopeful reading, e.g., “Americans overwhelmingly reject Trump’s corruption”, cannot be extracted from the corruption question alone. Some respondents probably were (1) thinking about Dem corruption, (2) distrusting both parties, or (3) accepting corruption while prioritizing something else. The poll does not indicate which explanation applies to each person.
Arguably, the most hopeful pro-democracy finding is voter’s desire for stronger congressional checks. That connects public dissatisfaction to a specific mechanism for limiting presidential power.
A reasonable synthesis of all this date might be that MAGA has not secured the public’s acquiescence, and pro-democratic resistance has a substantial constituency. However, MAGA retains a cohesive base that will sustain the authoritarian and kleptocratic danger for the foreseeable future.
In other words, the exit polling gives reason to reject despair, but no reason to relax and go into business as usual mode. This data indicates that American politics still isn’t a matter of business as usual. MAGA demagoguery will at least continue as it has, or maybe more likely, expert demagogues will seek to up their aggression by improving the intensity and sophistication of their attacks on democracy, the rule of law, civil liberties and honest, competent democratic governance.
Q1: Assuming this exit poll data as described in this OP reasonably reflects reality, does the data personally feel more hopeful than threatening?
Q2: From this data can one reasonably believe that, at present, (1) most rank and file Dems and moderates see corruption and threats from the MAGA elites and MAGA politics and policy, while (2) most rank and file Repubs see corruption and threats from the Dems and Dem politics and policy?
Q3: In the long run, does radical right American authoritarianism and kleptocracy have a major advantage because those forces can block or limit opposition efforts to improve economic conditions for average people, allowing the radicals to claim that the opposition failed to deliver, and therefore people need to vote for the radical right again?
For better or worse, it looks like the House at least vote on starting impeachment proceedings against Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth. Rep. Thomas Massie (R-KY) filed multiple articles of impeachment and is trying to force a vote on the measure as soon as it can be done. If that goes ahead, the House will very likely convict him, but the Senate will very likely acquit him. Conviction in the Senate require 67 votes and the Dems will have 56 at most after Alaska and Mississippi elections are decided. Right now, the Dems have 54.
Massie says there are eight separate impeachment offenses. They accuse Hegseth of engaging in unlawful war or military actions in Iran, Yemen, and Venezuela, “ignoring laws that minimize civilian casualties”, engaging in extrajudicial killings; and suppressing free speech rights.
There is more than plenty of evidence to impeach Hegseth. A lot of the evidence is clearly laid out in this 35 minute video by comedian John Oliver. Sure, Oliver is a comedian, not a professional investigator. But that fact doesn’t negate the video clips conveying plenty of damning evidence against Hegseth. We can see and hear it on our own. Committing murder and/or war crimes are among various bits of vicious naughtiness the evidence shows that Hegseth is responsible for.
Hegseth really did commit murder, commit war crime or both
Why bother and waste time?
Would there be any point to impeachment and then a trial and acquittal in the Senate? Would that necessarily be futile and a waste of the extremely precious, maybe very short time that the Dems have in power? Yes, two years is very short time in this context. Some say it’s a waste of dem time in power because the Senate won’t convict. It is probably true that MAGA Senators would vote to acquit. But that ignores the detailed, evidence-based public record that a House impeachment would leave, even if the Senate acquits. Some of the video evidence that Oliver shows really does deserve to be memorialized in a detailed, professional public document.
If the dems don’t spend much House time with this, letting staff and investigators collect the evidence, organize it and write the report, a House impeachment ought to take a limited amount of time the House is in session and debating this. The impeachment document will be of value.
Q1: Assuming the Senate acquits him, is the public record it would create worth impeaching Hegseth?
Q2: Would it be worth impeachment if the Senate votes to convict him?
The ancient war can be described different ways. One way to understand it as a tension between two conflicting human tendencies, one is toward concentrating wealth and power in the hands of one ruler or a small elite, roughly, authoritarianism, vs. the other which is toward distributing both more broadly, roughly, democracy. Of course, a democratic system doesn’t necessarily always mean that wealth and power will be reasonably distributed. One can argue that modern America under MAGA control is an example of such a “bad” democracy.
Through history, some people have understood and commented on the nature of the endless war.
Notice that Jefferson packaged corruption with tyranny — sound familiar?
The unitary executive structure that MAGA authoritarianism is building is Adams’ “One Assembly”
Evidence the 2026 election did not change MAGA’s war mindset
Maybe recovering from shock at the outcome, and despite Trump saying he will accept the election results, now he’s starting to recover to his old vicious, vengeful self. Trump is calling for criminal inquiry over allegations of extortion by Dems who had threatened Attorney General Todd Blanche and other administration officials with impeachment. Trump says those officials had committed no impeachable offences, so the Dems belong in jail. That’s full-blown tyranny in action.
Also, Trump promoted the well-known racist Steven Miller to be his chief of staff. Miller’s racism is cruel, aggressive and out in the open. Besides Miller’s blatant lie that the GOP is more popular than ever, he made crystal clear his intent to support Trump as dictator at all costs. Trump clearly signals his unwillingness to fight and oppose Dems in congress.
After regaining composure, Trump is even starting to question the outcome of the 2026 elections. Earlier, he said he would accept the outcome. Now maybe he doesn’t, regardless of what he says.
Q1: Have the 2026 election results mostly quelled the ancient war, at least for a while?
Q2: Can the Dems meaningfully overcome the power of MAGA Senators’ filibuster, Trump’s promised vetoes, an authoritarian, completely corrupted USSC and MAGA political party who usually defend Trump, and an authoritarian, completely corrupted DOJ and FBI who serve as his personal law harassers and enemy persecutors?
Ensuring Accountability for All Agencies (Feb. 2025 Executive Order) — It shall be the policy of the executive branch to ensure Presidential supervision and control of the entire executive branch. ….. However, previous administrations have allowed so-called “independent regulatory agencies” to operate with minimal Presidential supervision. These regulatory agencies currently exercise substantial executive authority without sufficient accountability to the President, and through him, to the American people. Moreover, these regulatory agencies have been permitted to promulgate significant regulations without review by the President. (comment: this is Trump’s clearest expression of authoritarian unitary executive intent; here he calls independent federal agencies “so-called ‘independent regulatory agencies’”, clearly rejecting congressional oversight functions and claiming dictator-level power)
Twisting Stephen Miller’s Words (FactCheck, 2017) — Well, I think that it’s been an important reminder to all Americans that we have a judiciary that has taken far too much power and become in many cases a supreme branch of government. ….. The end result of this, though, is that our opponents, the media and the whole world will soon see as we begin to take further actions, that the powers of the president to protect our country are very substantial and will not be questioned. (comment: this probably is Miller’s clearest expression of support for dictator-level unitary executive power)
Trump sends ‘clear message’ to Democrats with Miller promotion — President Trump sent a blunt message to the incoming Democratic majority on Capitol Hill by tapping Stephen Miller to be his new chief of staff, setting up what is likely to be a contentious two years between both ends of Pennsylvania Avenue. ….. “They are not going to slow down on executive power, executive orders, and regulations. Stephen is going to move aggressively on all of that.”
I have met Stephen Miller – they call him Voldemort for good reason — He is, they say, Donald Trump without the sense of humour. ….. At school, Miller was known for baiting liberal-minded peers and teachers, reportedly throwing rubbish on the floor and demanding the cleaning staff pick it up. “Am I the only one here who is sick and tired of being told to pick up my trash when we have plenty of janitors who are paid to do it for us?” he once said. ….. Miller cast himself as a free-speech champion. An aversion to immigration drove his trajectory from California schooldays to Duke University, where he read politics, and later to Breitbart, the right-wing news website. When Trump declared, “Our whole country is rotting, like a third-world country,” Miller emailed friends: “Trump gets it… I wish he’d run for president.” A year later, Trump launched his campaign, and Miller, barely 30, joined it.
Stephen Miller Goes Full Sycophant in Bonkers Trump Tribute — “Let me tell you, if it wasn’t for President Trump, the United States of America would not exist right now. This man saved America,” Miller declared. “He saved our military from collapse. He saved our economy from destruction. He saved our border from annihilation. And he saved our country from threats at home and abroad, which would have been the end of the American dream forever,” he continued, without offering any evidence to support his assertions.