Etiquette



DP Etiquette

First rule: Don't be a jackass. Most people are good.

Other rules: Do not attack or insult people you disagree with. Engage with facts, logic and beliefs. Out of respect for others, please provide some sources for the facts and truths you rely on if you are asked for that. If emotion is getting out of hand, get it back in hand. To limit dehumanizing people, don't call people or whole groups of people disrespectful names, e.g., stupid, dumb or liar. Insulting people is counterproductive to rational discussion. Insult makes people angry and defensive. All points of view are welcome, right, center, left and elsewhere. Just disagree, but don't be belligerent or reject inconvenient facts, truths or defensible reasoning.

Monday, November 16, 2026

Maybe an awakening is underway

 


Some commentary from the punditocracy seems to reflect a better understanding of the nature of the profound mess we got ourselves into. Maybe the MSM is regrowing a pair after the MAGA party tore them off but then got trounced in the last election.

An NYT opinion piece, A Republican Party That’s Learned Nothing, succinctly states the core of the problem we still face: Republicans who want to revive the party without confronting or defying Trump are fooling themselves. There is no path back to decency — or to constitutional governance — without defeating MAGA. ….. The stage has been set for a Republican civil war, and every American should be rooting for the revival of a decent, conservative Republican Party. Our nation’s future may depend on it.

Another NYT opinion, Americans Are Worried About More Than Prices, argues there is reason for hope we can start to crawl out of the deep hole we’re in: But it would be wrong, and ultimately dangerous, to interpret voters’ preference for Democrats exclusively as a reaction to rising prices. This election was also a profoundly antifascist one. ….. [The election] was also powered by a deep sense of moral revulsion and indignation that has only gained force since 2024. [The midterms] also showed that ordinary people understand that the stakes are much more existential. This is a fight for a livable democratic future that we can’t afford to lose.

A NYT opinion assessing dem elites, Nate Silver’s Unscientific, Totally Subjective Breakdown of the Democrats’ Future Stars, comments on the depth of the mess: For rising stars like Mr. Forstag, a former wildland firefighter, the pitch is often that they were just trying to do their jobs until the outrageousness of the country’s predicament pushed them into politics. For experienced politicians, it’s more about being done with the nice guy act.

If those assessments are correct, it is a hopeful sign that voters, and maybe also the MSM, do not see MAGA as conservative, which it clearly isn’t. MAGA is authoritarian and deeply corrupt. Some people, looking at the evidence of what MAGA has done, see it as it fascism.

But by picking Steven Miller and Jim Jordan, Trump and MAGA politicians in the House are clearly signaling they are not going to abandon their aggressive corruption or fascist agenda. A moral re-awakening among Republican politicians is needed, but probably unlikely to happen soon. Maybe that will change closer to the 2028 elections. Or, maybe American politics at the national level will stay broken for some years to come.

Q1: Will MAGA’s constant slandering of dem progressives and moderates as radical authoritarian leftists and communists resonate with the non-MAGA public as much as it has in the past?

Q2: Is it sufficiently evidence-based and rational to call MAGA politics and policy fascist, which would include autocrats like Trump, oligarchs, and Christian nationalist theocrats?

Sunday, November 15, 2026

A simple plan that the dems could choose

 

There is an easy way to make the gigantic differences between the dems and MAGA politicians easy to understand and hard to deny. Write and bring to votes laws that deal as narrowly as possible with a single item. No distractions, just one thing focused on. Dems could choose narrow laws that repair at least some of the vast damage that MAGA has caused.

The advantage of short, single-issue bills is that they give members of Congress little room to hide why they oppose them.

For example, a one bill, one issue plan could include individual bills that (1) restore veterans’ exemption from SNAP’s work-reporting time limit without changing anything else in the existing SNAP food assistance law, (2) require background checks for all gun sales, (3) restore previously existing fines for excessive methane pollution, (4) protect drinking water by banning a specific forever chemical. Just one thing at a time, and (5) reinstate abortion rights as they were under Roe v. Wade. Polls usually show that most Americans would support laws like that.

There are dozens of examples of such MAGA damage that could be put in short, single-issue bills that most Americans support. Forcing MAGA politicians to vote against simple laws the public wants leaves them no place to hide for the 2028 and later elections. The dems could choose to just keep it simple like this. It leaves MAGA politicians no place to hide, and no good way to spin their votes into something false.

But will they keep it simple?

Probably not. Given their track record of arrogant cluelessness and the bad influence from special interest money, that seems to be an unlikely way for the dems to spend their precious time with congressional power. Doing business as usual is most likely how the they will proceed. If they do, voters will probably wind up putting MAGA politicians back in charge of congress in 2028.

Q: Is writing and forcing votes on single-issue bills, even if they are vetoed or filibustered, a reasonable tactic for the dems to try to implement now, and then use that record in the 2028 elections?

Saturday, November 14, 2026

MAGA elites plan to fight hard and dirty

 


Accumulated evidence since the 2026 midterm elections makes it a near-certainty that Trump, MAGA elites and their demagoguery industry plan to continue, probably intensify, their war against the dems, the public interest, inconvenient truth, good faith reasoning, democracy, the rule of law, honest, competent government, and probably also civil liberties. There is no significant evidence that Trump, MAGA elites, or their major financial backers care about the public vote against them. They plan to fight, fight, fight. So far, there is no significant evidence of moderation or a closer alignment with the public interest.

To MAGA elites, what voters said just does not matter. Some of them are telling us the voters made a mistake or were ignorant, e.g., House speaker Mike Johnson said that voters made the “wrong choice”. In his usual cynical bad faith style, Trump said that “we couldn’t get the word across” about how better than great the economy is, i.e., “phenomenal”, even though most voters believed the economy isn’t better than great for them.

The midterm elections did not limit Trump’s appetite for exercising power without accountability. The emerging response points toward escalation, not accommodation. We can expect more intimidation, obstruction, and efforts to portray legal congressional oversight scrutiny of presidential power and policy as vicious tyrannical persecution. The NYT reports in an article, As Congress Plans Investigations, White House Prepares Ferocious Response, that the White House has been preparing an aggressive campaign to thwart the incoming Democratic Congress.

MAGA’s attacks are well beyond ordinary partisan disagreement. In a letter to Representative Robert Garcia, White House counsel Will Scharf warned that Democrats’ investigative tactics could cross into “blatant criminality”. Trump has called legal investigative requests “extortion,” while MAGA extremist Attorney General Todd Blanche posited criminal investigations of Democrats. MAGA’s authoritarian tactic here is unmistakable. MAGA officials facing scrutiny threaten to flip the legally empowered dem investigators into criminal defendants. That is about as bad as bad faith politics can get.

The next level of bad faith down after that level of moral rot MAGA politics is the government shooting people in the streets for “retribution”, i.e., revenge. That is something Trump has made clear he is OK with, e.g., “Can’t you just shoot them, just shoot them in the legs or something”?

The stakes for MAGA elites and allied special interests are gigantic. That explains why the impending political war matters a hell of a lot for them. The dem’s planned oversight inquiries concern Trump-family enrichment, cryptocurrency ventures, corporate influence, and presidential construction projects. Apparently, the sleaze related to Trump’s idiotic, ego-driven construction projects is so bad that Trump is having document destroyed so there is less evidence of crimes for the dems to find. Senator Richard Blumenthal is asking whether corporate donations coincided with contracts, dismissed lawsuits, or regulatory favors. These are questions that require evidence for answers. Evidence is necessary to find criminality.

Two prominent MAGA demagoguery tactics

1. Making the mental state of revenge illegal: So far, two post-election tactics are prominent in MAGA’s bad faith demagoguery arsenal. The first is to attack and undermine dems’ legal oversight as illegal or unwarranted vengeance. Of course the logic flaw in that is that within the scope of legal oversight, a motive of vengeance can exist.

Trump and MAGA elites failed to fix that problem by passing a law making it illegal to have a mental state that includes revenge, even if revenge-driven actions are within existing oversight law. Since Trump and MAGA elites has stated that revenge they engage in is legal, a hypothetical MAGA law to ban revenge as a motive would have to apply only to dems and opponents of MAGA politics or policy. Of course, such a law would be unconstitutional, even with our current extremist, radical right MAGA USSC.

2. Cherry-picking and distorting dem statements: MAGA demagogues are already cherry picking dem post-election statements, some of them stupid. Bad faith MAGA demagogues say that those assertions are dem policy that will be passed into law, even thought the chance of that is very low. MAGA Senators will filibuster, and Trump will veto. In their irrational exuberance, some dems are saying some stupid things, e.g., get rid of ICE. MAGA demagogues are picking up those statements and demagoguing them into exaggerated horrors. The White House, and MAGA politicians and demagogues are already collecting the most sweeping Democratic statements and presenting them as the party’s collective agenda.

Unfortunately, there are lots of dem statements to cherry pick and distort. Here’s some of them Trump put in a Nov. 12, 2026 Executive Order, “Democrats Will Help Us”: Caravans March North as Dems Vow to Reopen the Border. President Trump Won’t Let It Happen. Trump says “Congressional Democrats are vowing to abolish ICE, dismantle DHS, stop deportations, and hand out amnesty while border-state Democrats cut off cooperation on immigration enforcement”.

Q1: How effective for most Americans will Trump and elite MAGA allegations probably be that legal dem oversight is just baseless revenge and thus not credible, regardless of the evidence dems find and present, e.g., will that con lots of Americans into a belief that legal oversight findings are illegal or otherwise not credible or fair?

Q2: How effective for most Americans will Trump and elite MAGA allegations probably be that context-free, cherry-picked dem statements reflect radical leftist extremism or communist tyranny that will catastrophically endanger American safety, lives and values?

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Debates over priorities and policies have begun

 

A deferred maintenance 
pterodactyl

Context

Aside from impeaching corrupt, incompetent MAGA authoritarians like Hegseth, Todd Blanche, and Trump himself, there is vast damage that MAGA policy has left in its wake. For people concerned about the public interest, rule of law, democracy and honest, competent government, the damage is ghastly everywhere one looks. Trump and MAGA elites have severely damaged the environment-global warming-pollution, a major matter of high public interest and source of public political power. That poser has been stripped away from the people and public interest and given to special interests. They can now profit from what now is fairly close to an unregulated sector of the economy.

That is just one slice of Trump/MAGA elite damage among many slices. The slices are huge, not little.

An environmental policy compromise is on the table, take it or leave it?

An article by the NYT Editorial Board, Democrats, Take the Deal, captures what some, maybe most, upcoming internal dem party disagreements will look like. There is a proposed congressional bill that apparently has enough bipartisan congressional support to override Trump’s veto, assuming he vetoes the bill if it passes congress. Some dems oppose it because it isn’t good enough.

The editors argue that Dems should help pass the bipartisan permitting-reform bill now, rather than wait until they control Congress in January to pursue legislation they like better. The central claim is that speeding up construction, especially for clean-energy projects and transmission lines, advances both energy affordability for consumers and climate protections.

One argument for the current bill is that it can be passed now and probably survive becoming actual law. Another argument is that current permitting rules are now counterproductive. They are barriers to doing anything at all unless political opposition and years of lawsuits are overcome. Laws designed to protect the environment now delay infrastructure needed to reduce emissions, lower electricity prices, and improve reliability. The editors argue that blocking construction often protects existing fossil-fuel interests at the cost of the environment.

Clean energy desperately needs new transmission lines and associated infrastructure. Wind and solar projects cannot deliver their full benefits without power lines connecting them to consumers. The Editors cite a Quebec–New England transmission project that took about a decade to complete but supplies roughly one-fifth of Massachusetts’s electricity demand. That is projected to save its consumers about $50 million annually.

A counterargument is that the bill’s its fossil-fuel provisions are too generous to the carbon energy sector. Supporters of the bill argue that overall climate benefits outweigh effects of those provisions. Although the proposed bill eases construction of oil and gas infrastructure, the editors cite modeling analysis that projects reduced power-sector greenhouse gas emissions by as much as 18% by 2040, partly by nearly tripling more energy-efficient high-voltage electricity transmission capacity.

The editors also argue that the bill provides benefits beyond clean energy. First, permitting delays seriously slow road-safety improvements and sewage repairs, both of which have been deferred for decades. Second, the bill includes a provision requiring data-center operators to pay the full electricity costs they impose, rather than shifting those costs to other consumers. Arguably, that is pro-reasonably regulated capitalism, and therefore pro-public interest.

America’s unmet infrastructure investment needs run into the trillions of dollars. Postponing necessary maintenance and repairs can turn manageable problems into much more expensive rehabilitation or replacement projects. That increases the risk of service disruptions, closures, and outright failure.

The chickens want to come home to roost, but can they? Eventually the already overgrown chickens will morph into aggressive, hungry pterodactyls.

New & improved deferred maintenance pterodactyls!

Q: Should the dems accept and pass the current bipartisan infrastructure bill, or should they wait and fight, fight fight!?

Some info sources:

2025 Report Card for America’s Infrastructure

2022 CNWS Data: Needs Dashboard — Total needs $630,067,255,205

The Deferred Maintenance Backlog for the Military Services’ Buildings (Aug. 2024) — The four services had about $50 billion in deferred maintenance on their bases; the Army and the Navy accounted for about 70 percent of the backlog. (comment: there’s serious deferred maintenance costs everywhere you look)

IBA Review of the FY 2026-2030 Five-Year Capital Infrastructure Planning Outlook (San Diego) — prolonged financial constraints and limited dedicated funding have resulted in significant underinvestment in that infrastructure, creating a projected $6.51 billion funding shortfall over the next five years, as outlined in the CIP Outlook. Given the City’s capital infrastructure needs far exceed available financial resources, it will be critical to prioritize investments strategically during the annual budget process. Without additional funding, many identified infrastructure needs will remain unaddressed, leading to further asset deterioration, expensive emergency repairs, and inefficient resource allocation. (comment: that is happening all over America, not just San Diego)