Christian nationalism's vision of theocracy comes into focus

Theocratic Christian nationalist (CN) elites and their dogma are generally bigoted, racist, intolerant, cruel and pro-fascism. Evidence of that is clear in the public record. Christian nationalism is historically linked to antisemitism, white supremacy, and a goal of building and maintaining a white Christian theocracy. Poll data indicates that most rank and file CN supporters either are unaware of it, or they do not understand what the CN political movement and ideology are or stand for. There is a major gap between CN elites’ articulated ideology and the lay public’s understanding. Many CN supporters are participating in the project without understanding the implications of what they support.

There's a lot of ignorance going on in American politics, to say the least.

Making the US military Christian nationalist

The loyal idiot Pete Hegseth that Trump installed and Senate Republicans confirmed to run the pentagon is an outspoken CN theocrat. A Salon article discusses new pentagon policy to instill CN dogma as the dominant religious mindset for religious indoctrination in the US military. What Trump and Hegseth did was reduce the number of recognized religious groups from 211 to 31. 

As is usual for morally rotted MAGA politics, we are lied to about why this is being done. The lie is that CN elites want to “streamline” military chaplaincy and related services. The truth is that CN dogma is highly intolerant of all kinds of things. That includes extreme intolerance of other religions (and no religion). That includes some groups that see themselves as "Christian". With its increasing power, CN theocracy is increasingly able to push aside other religions and subordinate them to CN elites' definition of what groups of Christians are Christian and what aren't.

CN dogma is very theocratic and theological. It is Old Testament intolerant, vengeful, aggressive and angry.

Anyway, the new Trump/Hegseth scheme says there are 21 different groups of Christians and 10 groups of whatever else. Jews, Muslims, Hindus, and other major religions are all stuffed into single undifferentiated big wads. Other groups like atheists, humanists, pagans, Wiccans, and etc., are simply gone and no longer recognized to even exist.  The Trump/Hegseth CN theocratic agenda clearly signals Christian superiority by openly marginalizing non‑Christians as less than fully American, including in the military. 

The Mormons are unhappy -- they  don't even have a religion

How CN dogma treats the Mormons is weird. In the CN's vision, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter‑day Saints (Mormonism) is not counted under any of the CN's “Christian” labels. That accords with Hegseth’s rigid belief in evangelical claims that Mormons are not Christians. Mormons are excluded from the “Christian” umbrella, and they do not get recognition as a distinct non‑Christian faith on equal footing with, Judaism or Islam. In other words, CN dogma seems to see Mormonism as a cult. Calling it a cult is common among evangelical Christian elites. That is how they believe their God sees it, or tells them to see it. 

This points out the incoherence of CN's intolerant religious dogma. Intolerance does lead to various stupidities like this. 

Whaddabout the Catholics? 

This is not going to end with CN elites treating Mormonism like crap. The important, juicy target is Catholics. At present, there is an uneasy ceasefire between elite CN evangelicals and the Catholic church. For now, the Catholics are too powerful for the evangelicals to go to war with. 

But once evangelical CN elites like Russell Vought believe they have sufficient staying power in government after Trump is gone, they will go after the Catholics too. Assuming evangelical elites can build a persistent American theocracy, the question is when will the split with the Catholics come, not if.

A bit of CN history

The Salon article mentions a little CN history worth considering. The article says that Gerald L K Smith, a pro‑Huey Long organizer, founded explicitly “Christian Nationalist” organizations like the Christian Nationalist Crusade, the Christian Nationalist Party, and The Cross and the Flag in the 1940s. He and those groups promoting a white Christian America built on antisemitism and anti‑Black racism. Smith’s dogma sees communism as a “Jewish plot” that uses Black Americans to overthrow white Christian civilization. His definition of “Christian” excluded many Catholics and Mormons.

The CN elite R.J. Rushdoony, a foundational figure in Christian Reconstructionism, is frequently quoted in CN literature as saying that Christians have a “mandate, a commission, a holy responsibility to reclaim the land for Jesus Christ, to have dominion in civil affairs” and that “civil government must be brought under the law of God”. As we all know, that God opposes abortions, birth control, same-sex marriage, voting rights, minority protections, and some other civil liberties.

None of that has changed much or at all. CN elites are corrupt authoritarian monsters. In some ways, they are different from the monstrous Trump himself. And since God is on their theocratic side, if they get power, they very well could wind up being even worse than Trump's criminality, deep moral rot, intolerance and hateful vengeance. 

An American Taliban?

A comparison of American CN elites with the Afghan Taliban elites starts to come into focus. If one thinks through some plausible implications of an intolerant, vengeful God's law-driven Old Testament theocracy, visions of an American Bible version of the Taliban can come to mind. It ought to come to mind.

Fortunately, we're not there yet. With some luck, we'll never get there. But the American CN theocratic threat is real, powerful, and right now. Hegseth is just God's bad breath that powerful CN theocrats want everyone to smell, fear and live with. 

Q: Are most rank and file CN supporters really so ignorant they don't understand what they support, or is the CN movement nothing like how the Salon article portrays it, or is there something else different going on here?